| Place | Bib | Name | Time | State | Residence | Citizenship |
| 3 | 16 | Abdi Abdirahman | 2:11:23 | AZ | United States | USA |
| 5 | 14 | Shadrack Biwott | 2:12:01 | CA | United States | USA |
| 8 | 12 | Tyler Pennel | 2:15:09 | NC | United States | USA |
| 9 | 20 | Ben Payne | 2:15:46 | CO | United States | USA |
| 10 | 18 | Patrick Smyth | 2:16:34 | NM | United States | USA |
| 11 | 8 | Craig Leon | 2:17:14 | OR | United States | USA |
| 13 | 10 | Christo Landry | 2:19:14 | NC | United States | USA |
| 14 | 25 | Brendan Martin | 2:19:34 | NY | United States | USA |
| 17 | 15 | Matthew Llano | 2:20:15 | AZ | United States | USA |
| 19 | 17 | Tim Ritchie | 2:21:09 | CT | United States | USA |
| 24 | 33 | Michael Cassidy | 2:24:02 | NY | United States | USA |
| 25 | 24 | John Dewitt | 2:24:35 | WI | United States | USA |
| 27 | 22 | Tyler McCandless | 2:25:56 | CO | United States | USA |
| 28 | 243 | Jeffrey Stein | 2:26:39 | DC | United States | USA |
| 30 | 32 | Jerry Faulkner | 2:27:01 | NY | United States | USA |
| 31 | 30 | Zachary Ornelas | 2:27:02 | MI | United States | USA |
| 32 | 238 | Charles Remillard | 2:27:09 | NY | United States | USA |
| 34 | 31 | Matt Hensley | 2:28:24 | CO | United States | USA |
| 39 | 213 | Brian Finnel | 2:30:07 | WI | United States | USA |
| 40 | 225 | Matthew Lawder | 2:30:39 | NY | United States | USA |
| 41 | 220 | Max Haines-Stiles | 2:30:41 | CA | United States | USA |
| 43 | 229 | Trevor Middleton | 2:32:37 | NY | United States | USA |
| 45 | 42 | Michael Wardian | 2:33:18 | VA | United States | USA |
| 46 | 1095 | Kevin Hoyt | 2:33:24 | CT | United States | USA |
| 47 | 1102 | Thomas Petersen | 2:33:26 | MA | United States | USA |
| 48 | 1037 | Andrew Madison | 2:33:33 | MD | United States | USA |
| 49 | 1054 | Nicholas Roosa | 2:33:38 | NY | United States | USA |
| 51 | 1366 | Christopher Legh | 2:34:19 | CO | United States | USA |
| 52 | 233 | Brendon O'leary | 2:34:33 | MA | United States | USA |
| 55 | 1109 | Dougie Coffed | 2:34:42 | GA | United States | USA |
| 56 | 624 | David Roeske | 2:34:49 | NY | United States | USA |
| 57 | 236 | Hugh Parker | 2:35:21 | NY | United States | USA |
| 61 | 1071 | Tim Harder | 2:35:55 | MA | United States | USA |
| 64 | 228 | Danny Machmueller | 2:36:29 | WI | United States | USA |
| 66 | 779 | George Darden | 2:36:47 | GA | United States | USA |
| 67 | 802 | Jeremiah Estes | 2:36:47 | KS | United States | USA |
| 69 | 1153 | Clayton Pierce | 2:37:26 | MA | United States | USA |
| 72 | 1101 | Ernesto Ramirez | 2:37:47 | IL | United States | USA |
| 74 | 2626 | Aaqib Syed | 2:37:57 | NY | United States | USA |
| 75 | 1149 | Philip Shaw | 2:38:02 | NH | United States | USA |
| 76 | 3606 | David Lukas | 2:38:02 | NJ | United States | USA |
| 77 | 1169 | Jordan Andersen | 2:38:11 | WA | United States | USA |
| 78 | 227 | Ben Leese | 2:38:22 | NY | United States | USA |
| 82 | 738 | Alexander Walsh | 2:39:01 | NY | United States | USA |
| 90 | 1031 | Norberto Robles | 2:39:38 | AZ | United States | USA |
| 91 | 222 | Hunter Hall | 2:39:46 | TN | United States | USA |
| 92 | 1132 | John Campagna | 2:40:24 | NY | United States | USA |
| 93 | 647 | Cory Helder | 2:40:24 | NY | United States | USA |
| 94 | 1543 | Alec Depaolis | 2:40:44 | NY | United States | USA |
| 96 | 1052 | Ian Blackwell | 2:40:50 | IL | United States | USA |
| 98 | 759 | Sam Teigen | 2:40:52 | NJ | United States | USA |
| 99 | 1326 | Turner Zamore | 2:40:56 | VT | United States | USA |
| 104 | 1175 | Kristopher Shold | 2:41:30 | FL | United States | USA |
| 107 | 1207 | Andrew Keller | 2:41:46 | PA | United States | USA |
| 109 | 1188 | Christopher Smith | 2:41:50 | NY | United States | USA |
| 110 | 1594 | Jotham Burnett | 2:41:51 | NH | United States | USA |
| 112 | 1027 | Brendon Moody | 2:42:02 | OH | United States | USA |
| 113 | 1306 | Enrique Sanchez | 2:42:09 | GA | United States | USA |
| 114 | 814 | Douglas Pierce | 2:42:09 | NY | United States | USA |
| 116 | 1297 | David Proffitt | 2:42:10 | CO | United States | USA |
| 117 | 2183 | Dennis Ryan | 2:42:15 | NY | United States | USA |
| 118 | 2308 | Adam Sullivan | 2:42:15 | MO | United States | USA |
| 120 | 1155 | Emmett Saulnier | 2:42:24 | OH | United States | USA |
| 122 | 1200 | Brian Falcone | 2:42:29 | WI | United States | USA |
| 129 | 1419 | Jatin Narang | 2:42:57 | MD | United States | USA |
| 132 | 641 | Stephen Kress | 2:43:16 | NY | United States | USA |
| 133 | 1312 | Scott Cichon | 2:43:18 | KS | United States | USA |
| 137 | 1198 | Timothy Clarke | 2:43:28 | NY | United States | USA |
| 138 | 4104 | Greg Rotman | 2:43:31 | MI | United States | USA |
| 139 | 736 | Bill Walkowicz | 2:43:31 | NY | United States | USA |
| 141 | 3350 | Candido Perez | 2:43:39 | NY | United States | USA |
| 142 | 642 | Daniel Goding | 2:43:39 | CO | United States | USA |
| 144 | 1432 | Matthew Wiltse | 2:43:40 | NV | United States | USA |
| 145 | 1186 | William Downing | 2:43:43 | NY | United States | USA |
| 146 | 1073 | Mickey Wilson | 2:43:43 | UT | United States | USA |
| 147 | 851 | Michael Fonder | 2:43:43 | NJ | United States | USA |
| 148 | 1576 | Lukas Obersamer | 2:43:49 | Austria | USA | |
| 150 | 813 | Michael Devito Jr | 2:43:57 | NY | United States | USA |
| 151 | 2187 | Nathaniel Brooks | 2:43:58 | NC | United States | USA |
| 156 | 1423 | Mike Treder | 2:44:15 | WI | United States | USA |
| 157 | 248 | Ryan Hendricks | 2:44:16 | TX | United States | USA |
| 160 | 249 | Peter Kazery | 2:44:33 | MS | United States | USA |
| 163 | 2551 | Daniel Kwon | 2:44:38 | NY | United States | USA |
| 164 | 4605 | David Blitzer | 2:44:41 | PA | United States | USA |
| 169 | 2621 | Travis Chewning-Kulick | 2:44:51 | NY | United States | USA |
| 170 | 1299 | Christopher Moutos | 2:44:55 | AR | United States | USA |
| 171 | 239 | Hector Rivera | 2:44:55 | NJ | United States | USA |
| 172 | 1329 | David Stroupe | 2:44:56 | NY | United States | USA |
| 173 | 1280 | Patrick Cutter | 2:45:20 | NY | United States | USA |
| 174 | 3106 | Zach Huseby | 2:45:21 | WY | United States | USA |
| 175 | 1161 | Kyle Hall | 2:45:25 | MN | United States | USA |
| 176 | 1068 | Jesse Murray | 2:45:27 | CA | United States | USA |
| 178 | 1514 | Bob Larue | 2:45:40 | IL | United States | USA |
| 180 | 604 | Philip Lang | 2:45:47 | NY | United States | USA |
| 186 | 1601 | Shelby Anderson | 2:45:52 | WI | United States | USA |
| 187 | 1263 | Matthew Hillyard | 2:46:00 | CA | United States | USA |
| 190 | 2468 | Andrew Mannisto | 2:46:14 | NV | United States | USA |
| 192 | 1250 | George Wright | 2:46:19 | NY | United States | USA |
| 194 | 1105 | Carlos Ruiz | 2:46:29 | OR | United States | USA |
| 195 | 1165 | Doug Galbavy | 2:46:29 | SD | United States | USA |
