| Place | Bib | Name | Time | State | Country | Citizenship |
| 7 | 3 | Abdi Abdirahman | 2:12:48 | AZ | United States | USA |
| 10 | 12 | Shadrack Biwott | 2:14:57 | CA | United States | USA |
| 11 | 11 | Meb Keflezighi | 2:15:29 | CA | United States | USA |
| 12 | 9 | Jared Ward | 2:18:39 | UT | United States | USA |
| 15 | 18 | Brendan Martin | 2:22:36 | NY | United States | USA |
| 25 | 1032 | Jordan Tropf | 2:28:19 | MD | United States | USA |
| 26 | 464 | Matt Lenehan | 2:28:26 | CA | United States | USA |
| 28 | 458 | Benjamin Mears | 2:29:12 | CA | United States | USA |
| 32 | 548 | David Saunders | 2:30:05 | NY | United States | USA |
| 33 | 1154 | Jake Kasperski | 2:30:06 | OH | United States | USA |
| 36 | 1117 | Kyle Larson | 2:30:51 | IL | United States | USA |
| 39 | 1107 | Mark Sidebottom | 2:31:24 | PA | United States | USA |
| 40 | 1019 | Lane Boyer | 2:31:26 | TN | United States | USA |
| 41 | 1024 | Broderick Gann | 2:31:33 | NY | United States | USA |
| 42 | 454 | Phillip Falk | 2:31:39 | NY | United States | USA |
| 43 | 474 | Logan Sherman | 2:31:47 | TX | United States | USA |
| 45 | 1415 | Matthew Farkas | 2:31:52 | IN | United States | USA |
| 50 | 468 | Brent Woodle | 2:32:55 | TX | United States | USA |
| 51 | 1373 | Joseph Schnitter | 2:33:05 | NY | United States | USA |
| 52 | 1039 | John Campagna | 2:33:08 | NY | United States | USA |
| 58 | 552 | Ben Leese | 2:34:03 | NY | United States | USA |
| 59 | 465 | Hugh Parker | 2:34:15 | NY | United States | USA |
| 60 | 1084 | Zachary Meineke | 2:34:22 | WI | United States | USA |
| 63 | 1147 | Greg Hutson | 2:34:38 | MO | United States | USA |
| 65 | 478 | David Roeske | 2:35:16 | NY | United States | USA |
| 67 | 483 | Brendon O'leary | 2:35:27 | MA | United States | USA |
| 68 | 480 | Daniel Wallace-Periac | 2:35:30 | NY | United States | USA |
| 69 | 1197 | Daniel Kittaka | 2:35:41 | IL | United States | USA |
| 73 | 1234 | Andrew Fenske | 2:36:27 | IL | United States | USA |
| 74 | 2447 | Joe Viavattine | 2:36:37 | MN | United States | USA |
| 75 | 456 | Josh Baden | 2:36:37 | KS | United States | USA |
| 78 | 473 | Knox Robinson | 2:36:46 | NY | United States | USA |
| 79 | 452 | Brent Frissora | 2:36:48 | NY | United States | USA |
| 80 | 457 | Ryan Millar | 2:36:49 | NY | United States | USA |
| 81 | 2030 | Christopher Petroff | 2:36:57 | CT | United States | USA |
| 85 | 1455 | Stephen Garner | 2:37:18 | MA | United States | USA |
| 89 | 1036 | Jamie Stroffolino | 2:37:38 | NY | United States | USA |
| 90 | 1353 | Michael Arnstein | 2:37:41 | NY | United States | USA |
| 91 | 1423 | Ryan Guldan | 2:37:46 | CO | United States | USA |
| 92 | 554 | Martin Huber | 2:37:51 | NY | United States | USA |
| 93 | 563 | Jeff Poindexter | 2:37:51 | NY | United States | USA |
| 96 | 481 | Jeffrey Redfern | 2:38:05 | DC | United States | USA |
| 97 | 1034 | Christopher Mutai | 2:38:07 | FL | United States | USA |
| 98 | 1366 | Mathew Moody | 2:38:08 | NY | United States | USA |
| 99 | 471 | Thomas McConville | 2:38:11 | NY | United States | USA |
| 100 | 1079 | Brett Burdick | 2:38:20 | IL | United States | USA |
| 101 | 1074 | Dan Swain | 2:38:20 | PA | United States | USA |
| 104 | 451 | Greg Cass | 2:38:46 | NY | United States | USA |
| 108 | 470 | Nobuyori Takeda | 2:39:11 | NY | United States | USA |
| 109 | 1521 | J Matthew Medeiros | 2:39:14 | NY | United States | USA |
| 110 | 604 | Daniel Goding | 2:39:20 | CO | United States | USA |
| 111 | 1080 | Alex Price | 2:39:25 | PA | United States | USA |
| 112 | 1602 | Bridger Tomlin | 2:39:35 | CO | United States | USA |
| 116 | 1730 | Michael Bailey | 2:39:48 | CA | United States | USA |
| 117 | 1070 | Andrew Keller | 2:39:48 | PA | United States | USA |
| 121 | 589 | Joshua Hatcher | 2:40:12 | NY | United States | USA |
| 128 | 1293 | Travis Hawkins | 2:40:56 | NY | United States | USA |
| 129 | 547 | Dale Hunter | 2:41:00 | WA | United States | USA |
| 130 | 1081 | Scott Allen | 2:41:09 | WI | United States | USA |
| 131 | 576 | Art Gunther | 2:41:18 | NY | United States | USA |
| 136 | 1941 | William Appman | 2:41:30 | NJ | United States | USA |
| 142 | 2303 | Nicholas Lawyer | 2:41:49 | OH | United States | USA |
| 144 | 1268 | Tony White | 2:42:03 | TN | United States | USA |
| 147 | 561 | Alexander Walsh | 2:42:08 | NY | United States | USA |
| 148 | 1261 | Connor Roche | 2:42:09 | CO | United States | USA |
| 149 | 4027 | Brian Scheall | 2:42:10 | FL | United States | USA |
| 151 | 2338 | Aaron Becker | 2:42:20 | IN | United States | USA |
| 154 | 1208 | Robert Wiegand, Jr | 2:42:30 | IL | United States | USA |
| 155 | 569 | Richard Velazquez | 2:42:32 | NY | United States | USA |
| 156 | 1843 | Jack Johnson | 2:42:33 | IA | United States | USA |
| 157 | 1160 | Hunter Sapienza | 2:42:36 | WA | United States | USA |
| 160 | 1554 | Sean Kinne | 2:42:39 | DC | United States | USA |
| 161 | 1049 | Mike Foley | 2:42:42 | CA | United States | USA |
| 162 | 1078 | Narciso Mejia | 2:42:45 | NY | United States | USA |
| 168 | 2004 | Michael Wurzbacher | 2:43:00 | DC | United States | USA |
| 169 | 560 | John Mulvaney | 2:43:02 | NY | United States | USA |
| 179 | 1809 | Patrick Wortner | 2:43:35 | NY | United States | USA |
| 180 | 1120 | Patrick Burke | 2:43:38 | NY | United States | USA |
| 183 | 852 | Nicholas Thompson | 2:43:50 | NY | United States | USA |
| 185 | 1235 | Tim Meigs | 2:43:52 | NC | United States | USA |
| 186 | 485 | Todd Braje | 2:43:54 | CA | United States | USA |
| 187 | 1513 | Nikolas Bowie | 2:43:55 | MA | United States | USA |
| 188 | 562 | Christopher Wolf | 2:43:59 | NY | United States | USA |
| 191 | 594 | Cary Segall | 2:44:05 | NY | United States | USA |
| 192 | 2400 | Eric Seelbach | 2:44:08 | IL | United States | USA |
| 193 | 1157 | Samuel Bell | 2:44:09 | OH | United States | USA |
| 195 | 577 | Isaac Markel | 2:44:18 | NJ | United States | USA |
| 197 | 1254 | Austen Davenport | 2:44:23 | IN | United States | USA |
| 198 | 1330 | Steven Waite | 2:44:24 | CA | United States | USA |
| 200 | 1733 | Patrick Condon | 2:44:25 | MA | United States | USA |
| 208 | 1507 | Daniel Brinkenhoff | 2:44:47 | CA | United States | USA |
| 211 | 2853 | Bradford Ackerman | 2:44:51 | NJ | United States | USA |
| 212 | 1040 | Aaron Lozier | 2:44:53 | NY | United States | USA |
| 215 | 2323 | Eric Glaubke | 2:44:57 | MN | United States | USA |
| 217 | 586 | Spencer Duhaime | 2:45:02 | NY | United States | USA |
| 226 | 7081 | Marc Violone | 2:45:08 | NY | United States | USA |
| 232 | 608 | Stephen Young | 2:45:21 | FL | United States | USA |
| 238 | 1545 | Topher Gaylord | 2:45:33 | MD | United States | USA |
| 239 | 1029 | Chase Pizzonia | 2:45:38 | NY | United States | USA |
| 240 | 3151 | Andrew Roach | 2:45:41 | MD | United States | USA |
